Updates to Catholic Investing Guidelines Signal a Shift

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) approved new socially responsible investment (SRI) guidelines for Catholic investing in November 2021, its first notable changes to the guidelines since 2003.1 The update includes additions to investment restrictions; however, the restrictions do not materially affect the underlying indices tracked by the Global X S&P 500 Catholic Values ETF (CATH) and the Global X S&P Catholic Values Developed ex-U.S. ETF (CEFA). One significant change includes the Pope calling for the Catholic community to take the threat of climate change seriously and promote more active engagement efforts and impact investing.2

Key Takeaways

  • The Catholic Church’s revised guidelines add restrictions related to existing excluded themes, such as certain healthcare practices, adult entertainment, controversial weapons, gambling, tobacco, and recreational cannabis.
  • The Church took a notable stance against climate change, sending a strong signal that companies who fail to incorporate policies related to the Paris Agreement will be excluded in the future.
  • SRI typically expresses values by using brute exclusions, but with this update, the Church takes a new approach, encouraging more proactive corporate engagement and impact investing opportunities.

Underlying Indexes Minimally Affected by the USCCB’s Revised Guidelines

Passively managed socially responsible investing funds track a specific index. SRI guidelines include a list of prohibited corporate activities or business models. Any company that participates in excluded categories is “screened” from, or taken out of, the index constituents and therefore the fund’s holdings.

CATH tracks an index that uses the S&P Catholic Values Indices Methodology. To help create the indices methodology to ensure their adherence to Catholic values, S&P consults with the Oblate International Pastoral Investment Trust, a charitable trust that invests alongside the values of Roman Catholic-related organizations. After reviewing the revised guidelines, S&P identified no immediate revisions to the existing methodology.

The new USCCB guidelines are grouped into five broad categories: Protecting Human Life, Protecting Human Dignity, Enhancing the Common Good, Pursuing Economic Justice, and Saving Our Global Home. Given their passively managed nature, the USCCB’s new restrictions affect the Global X Catholic Values ETFs, but their impact is expected to be minimal. The S&P Catholic Values Indices Methodology already included negative screens for certain healthcare activities, adult entertainment, and weapons prior to the revised guidelines. These types of restrictions have been foundational to Catholic SRI since its inception in 1991.

Church Codifies Its Commitment to Tackling Climate Change, Encourages Action

To achieve its investment objectives of investing in alignment with the values of the Catholic church, the USCCB outlined three strategies: Avoid Doing Harm through investment exclusions, Actively Work for Change through corporate engagement, and Promote the Common Good through impact investing. Active engagement efforts and impact investing are historically related to investment strategies such as actively managed funds and private markets, where measurable impact can be tied back to a specific investment. The investment strategy that utilizes investment restrictions to Avoid Doing Harm is most commonly found in passively managed fund vehicles.

Uniquely, the revised USCCB guidelines take a firm stance on climate change, as outlined in the Saving our Global Common Home category. The USCCB expects Catholic investors to do their part, not only through investment exclusions but also active corporate engagement and impact investing. As a result, we believe that Catholic investors may become one of the loudest voices pressing companies to set Paris-aligned carbon emissions reduction targets, prevent biodiversity loss, and ensure human rights compliance with the United Nations Global Compact.

In our view, the USCCB’s new climate-related priorities suggest that, if companies repeatedly fail to improve on these climate-related issues, they risk removal from an index. Last year, in preparation for the 26th United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP26), over 70 faith institutions with a total of $4.2 billion assets under management announced fossil fuel divestment commitments. The institutions committing to divest included the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Scotland and 15 Catholic dioceses in the United Kingdom and Ireland.3 Bishop Robert McElroy of San Diego even hinted at possible complete fossil fuel divestment in the future at the USCCB’s fall 2021 general assembly, reflecting how seriously Catholic leaders consider climate change.4

Exclusions No Longer the Church’s Only SRI Investment Strategy

Socially responsible investing through investment restrictions will likely remain the bedrock of Catholic investing. However, the USCCB’s new guidelines empower the Catholic community to go beyond exclusions and take a proactive approach to capital allocation, particularly on climate change. Greater corporate engagement activity from Catholic institutional investors appears likely. And on the impact investing side, the USCCB outlines possible private market partnerships with other non-profit organizations that align with its mission. More broadly, we believe that the USCCB’s new guidelines and proactive strategies signal how Catholic investing may evolve in the modern world.

 

Related ETFs

CATH: The Global X S&P 500 Catholic Values ETF (CATH) provides exposure to the companies within the S&P 500 whose business practices adhere to the Socially Responsible Investment Guidelines as outlined by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) and excludes those that do not.

CEFA: The Global X S&P Catholic Values Developed ex-U.S. ETF (CEFA) provides exposure to large cap companies in developed markets outside of the U.S., whose business practices adhere to the Socially Responsible Investment Guidelines of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB).

Click the fund name above to view current holdings. Holdings are subject to change. Current and future holdings are subject to risk.